The Perils of Speculating in Your TFSA
The Lure of the Tax-Free Millionaire Dream
Larry MacDonald of The Globe and Mail has highlighted remarkable success stories of investors turning their Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs) into million-dollar windfalls. With $102,000 in cumulative TFSA contribution room as of January 1, 2025 (for those eligible since 2009), such achievements are impressive but rare.
One featured investor, a retired firefighter, turned his TFSA into $1 million by betting on Canopy Growth (WEED) in 2015. By 2018, when TFSA room maxed at $57,500, he had sold his shares near their peak—before cannabis stocks plummeted. Today, WEED trades at $4.25, far below its 2018 high of $766.80 (split-adjusted). However, the firefighter later lost half his gains through poor investments, ultimately handing over management of his account to a professional investment team.
This story highlights the risky nature of speculative investing in TFSAs. While success is possible, the dangers far outweigh the rewards for most.
The Consequences of Speculative Investing
Permanent Loss of Contribution Room
TFSA overcontributions can lead to hefty penalties. Consider this scenario:
- You start 2024 with $100,000 in your TFSA and $7,000 in new contribution room.
- You max out your contributions in January, withdraw $40,000 in February, and then redeposit $40,000 in March after receiving a bonus.
From the CRA’s perspective, you’ve contributed $47,000 in 2024 ($7,000 + $40,000). The $40,000 withdrawal adds to your contribution room next year, not in the current calendar year. The result? A $40,000 overcontribution subject to a 1% monthly penalty.
If you don’t withdraw the excess, penalties escalate. For instance:
- $40,000 overcontribution in March 2024: $4,000 penalty by year-end.
- Overcontribution reduced to $33,000 because of $7,000 of new contribution room in 2025: $3,960 penalty.
- Overcontribution reduced to $25,500 because of $7,500 (assumed) of new contribution room in 2026: $3,060 penalty.
This cycle continues, with financial and emotional strain mounting as penalties pile up.
Behavioural Pitfalls
- Overconfidence Bias: Believing you have superior investing skills can lead to unjustified risks.
- Survivorship Bias: Stories of TFSA “winners” dominate the headlines, but countless others lose everything without fanfare.
The Better Way Forward
Reframe the TFSA’s Purpose
Think of your TFSA as a tool for long-term growth and specific savings goals—not a casino for risky bets.
The Power of Compounding
A disciplined, long-term strategy is key to maximizing the TFSA’s potential. For example:
- If you invested $102,000 (accumulated contribution room since 2009) in a 60% equity / 40% fixed-income portfolio earning 5% annually, your TFSA could grow to approximately $150,000 within a decade.
- Starting at age 18 in 2009 with consistent contributions and investing in a 100% equity ETF averaging 6.36% annual returns, you could accumulate $1 million by age 56 and nearly $2 million by age 65 (in nominal terms).
Strategies for Success
- Diversify: Spread investments across asset classes to reduce risk.
- Manage Risk: Use a clear investment policy statement to guide decisions.
- Balance Your Portfolio: Combine growth assets with stable investments to achieve steady compounding with minimized volatility.
These strategies help avoid concentration in speculative assets, reducing the chance of devastating losses.
But What If You Want to Speculate?
If you feel the need to try speculative investing:
- Limit it to a small, one-time allocation (e.g., 5% of your portfolio).
- Use a non-registered account for speculative bets. While gains are taxable, losses can offset other capital gains, reducing your tax liability.
The Joy of Financial Growth
Success doesn’t require high-stakes gambling. A thoughtful, diversified approach can lead to significant, tax-free growth over time—without the sleepless nights. Instead of chasing risky jackpots, let your TFSA work steadily toward a secure financial future.
A Call to Reflect and Act
For many DIY investors, speculative approaches can extend beyond their TFSAs and into other areas of their portfolio. The good news? It’s never too late to reassess your strategy and make choices that increase your chances of achieving sustainable, long-term success.
Here are a few practical steps to consider:
- Evaluate your current investments: Take a close look at your portfolio. Is it diversified? Does it align with a balanced approach suited to your risk tolerance and goals? If not, consider making adjustments to reduce unnecessary risks and ensure a more stable foundation for growth.
- Establish or revisit an Investment Policy Statement (IPS): If you often find yourself chasing market trends or the latest hot tips, a well-defined IPS can help you stay grounded. A clear plan provides a framework for decision-making, enabling you to focus on your goals rather than reacting to short-term market noise.
- Seek guidance when needed: While DIY investing can be rewarding, it’s worth reflecting on whether you have the time, expertise, and discipline to manage your portfolio effectively. Just as you might call a professional plumber to renovate a bathroom, there’s no shame—and often great wisdom—in delegating investment management to a qualified professional. By doing so, you can free up your time and energy for the things that matter most, while gaining confidence that your finances are in capable hands.
As we step into 2025 and beyond, I encourage you to take these reflections to heart. With careful planning and thoughtful action, you can lay the groundwork for financial security and peace of mind in the years ahead.
All the best in your investing journey!
This is the 274th blog post for Russ Writes, first published on 2025-01-06
If you would like to discuss this or other posts, connect on Facebook, Twitter aka X, LinkedIn, or Instagram.
Click here to contact me for an appointment.
Click here and select FinPlan30: Financial Planning in 30 min under Specific Questions for a 30-minute free no-obligation financial planning conversation.
Click here for a 2-week free trial of the Money Architect Financial Planning platform.
Disclaimer: This blog post is intended for general information and discussion purposes only. It should not be relied upon for investment, insurance, tax, or legal decisions.
Photo by PiggyBank on Unsplash